🟢 The conflicting business model of subscription

While Meta just announced a paying blue mark subscription for Facebook and Meta, it's worth questioning their logic, if there's a real strategy at play, and what subscription is as a business model anyway.

🟢 The conflicting business model of subscription
Photo by GR Stocks / Unsplash

After the recent series on the state of the GAFAMs in 2023, I wasn't planning on going back to discuss their strategies anytime soon. But here I am again as I was taken flat-footed by Facebook's (and Instagram's) announcement of offering a subscription model for $12 a month in exchange for a blue verification mark – $11.99 on the web and $14.99 on mobile, to be precise. OK, the move seems obvious. Zuckerberg is following up on Musk with a grand strategy, probably code-named  "Why The Hell Not?" to try and grab some more money.

It's not so simple and does elicit quite a few remarks about what subscriptions are as a business model.

Here we go:

The deal with subscriptions

First of all, it seems necessary to remind us why subscriptions exist. The core idea is that you will pay at a fixed frequency for an ongoing service. And there can be quite a few types of rationales around this transaction:

  1. The service can have a constant value, and by subscribing, you commit to being a long-term paying customer in exchange for a discount on the total value (this is the printed press model of yore).
  2. The service is a portfolio of bundled offers that you can consume as a super-user at your leisure in exchange for committing to a regular payment (think of it as a buffet).
  3. The service is accessible to anyone already paying for it, but by subscribing for an extra, you get a premium service (think VIP pass in various consumer markets).

We could go on with half a dozen more nuances, but essentially, subscriptions end up being about offering some customers a clear value at a discount in exchange for their long-term commitment. And, if, on the surface, it seems that Facebook is offering a VIP subscription (mode 3.) for its platform, it doesn't work.

Read the full article

Sign up now to read the full article and get access to all articles for subscribers only.

Already have an account? Sign in

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to innovation copilots.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.